Independent Survey Findings: Central Exuma Cays
A recent independent community survey conducted on Staniel Cay and Black Point in October 2025 offers valuable insight into how residents of the Central Exuma Cays view development, the environment, and the proposed Yntegra/Rosewood Hotels development. The results show a shared understanding that the future of the Central Exuma Cays depends on protecting the environment and the livelihoods it supports before pursuing any large-scale, environmentally harmful development. Residents expressed clear concern about the proposed dredging and seawall, and voiced strong support for small, low-impact development, and broad agreement that Crown Land decisions should be transparent and accountable to the Bahamian people.
Key Findings at a Glance
The survey provides one of the clearest pictures yet of how residents in the Central Exuma Cays view development and environmental protection. Beyond the numbers, the responses reveal shared priorities and lived experiences, a deep connection to the environment, concern for the future, and a desire for fairness in how decisions are made. The insights below capture some main themes that emerged throughout the report:
1. Environmental protection defines community priorities
Across both communities, there is near-unanimous agreement that protecting seagrass beds, coral reefs, marine life, and clean water is essential to daily life in the Central Exuma Cays. For residents, the environment isn’t a separate issue, it is the backbone of food security, livelihoods, and our identity. The health of these ecosystems is seen as directly tied to the health of the community itself.
2. Deep concern about large-scale coastal alteration
People expressed strong concern about Yntegra’s proposed 390’ seawall in the North Bay, dredging, and other development activities that will negatively impact coastal and marine environments. Many described these projects as damaging to the character of the area and the way of life that depends on its natural state.
3. Desire for smaller, sustainable development
When provided with a choice, residents favor smaller, solar-powered, low-impact resorts that have minimal impact on the environment over larger resorts that involve activities like dredging. This preference reflects a broader vision for “development that fits,” combining economic opportunity with stewardship of the islands’ natural and cultural heritage.
4. Fairness and accountability in Crown Land decisions
Many participants stressed that Crown Land belongs to Bahamians and should not be leased or granted to foreign developers without clear safeguards. Respondents called for rules that are the same for everyone and insisted on transparent, inclusive consultation processes.
5. Trust and governance gaps
There is widespread skepticism toward government oversight. Residents want stronger accountability, better enforcement of environmental rules, and more consistent communication. Trust is highest in scientists, environmental experts, and local representatives who are seen as objective and close to the community.
6. Mixed but cautious views on economic development
While some residents expressed optimism about jobs and new opportunities, many remain cautious about whether promised benefits will reach locals. There’s hope for balance and compromise, but a strong sense that the community’s environment and voice must come first.
SEA’s Perspective on the Survey
The survey confirms what members and supporters of SEA have been saying for months; environmental protection, community wellbeing, and fair decision-making are shared priorities. The people of the central Exuma Cays want to see development that respects local values, sustains livelihoods, and protects the natural systems that make these islands thrive. SEA continues to advocate for that vision: progress that respects and appreciates our environment and way of life.
These topline findings only scratch the surface. The full report contains detailed insights into how residents think about development, employment, and the long-term protection of their islands. It explores levels of trust in decision-makers, perceptions of transparency, and the importance of community involvement in shaping the future of the Central Exuma Cays. Together, these perspectives form one of the most comprehensive snapshots of community sentiment ever gathered for these two island communities.
Read the Full Report
For those who want to explore the complete findings, including methodology and approach, and full survey responses and community commentary, the Exuma Cays Community Survey Report can be downloaded below: